Claim Phone Numbers American Modern 1-800-543-2644 ASI Progressive 1-866-274-5677 Bristol West 1-800-274-7865 Connecticare 1-800-251-7722 Dairyland 1-800-334-0090 Foremost 1-800-527-3907 Good2Go 1-800-727-6664 Hagerty 1-800-922-4050 Harleysville 1-800-892-8877 Infinity 1-800-334-1661 Main Street America 1-877-425-2467 Metlife 1-800-854-6011 National General 1-888-325-1190 Nationwide 1-800-421-3535 Progressive 1-800-274-4499 Safeco 1-800-332-3226 State Auto 1-800-766-1853 Stillwater 1-800-220-1351 The Hartford 1-800-243-5860 Travelers 1-800-252-4633 UPC Insurance 1-888-256-3378 Utica First 1-800-456-4556
